Blueberry Pie

I had a revelation tonight I want to tell you about. I feel it is a novel idea, but I am sure R&O thought of it when they were writing or some scholar has already made note of it, but the personal revelation was quite cool.

I am reading a bio on Mary Martin and saw a picture of her as Nellie, so I listened to "A Wonderful Guy."

Here is my revelation:

Nellie Forbush is upset with Emile de Becque. This is made obvious by her song "I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair." Even later, when
Emile kisses her, she get's upset at the cat calls from the girls and doubts herself. Because of her anger, she is confused of her true feelings. Nellie's real discovery comes during the course of "A Wonderful Guy."

The song begins in a minor key. The angst is made apparent by the percussive, staccato interjections by the orchestra. This minor section comes across as very abrasive as she proclaims she does not like Emile. Then, you hear a silver lining occur in the words "Fearlessly, I'll face them and argue their doubts away..." She becomes open to the idea as if she is asking herself "Wait, why am I so stubborn?" Her heart begins to flutter as the orchestra leads into the up beat waltz meter.

"I'm as corny as Kansas in August" is Nellie's girlish, singing way of blushing. The music naturally starts to lilt and one just pictures Nellie sway
side to side as a smile grows larger and larger on her face. The music seems to swirl, climaxing when she sings "I'm in love..." in a metric, typical 4 + 4 cadence stating "I'm in love" 5 times. Nellie is so filled with joy, she can no longer sing and has to dance (ie, the natural progression). Well guess what, dance break.

As Nellie calms down a bit, the dance "slows" allowing Nellie to sing again. The women join Nellie in a supportive, making-fun-of-her-because-she-is-so-fickle kinda way.

Now comes the really cool part. Unlike the previous, guessable 8 bars of "I'm in love..." the music drops down in orchestration and dynamic. The waltz slowly builds alternating Nellie, girls, Nellie, girls. Now, we, as the listener, expect "I'm in love" only 5 times. When the "I'm in loves" continue, it is rather shocking. We expect it in 4 more bars, equaling a very natural 12. But, the excitement/orchestrations/dynamics grow as Nellie can no longer hold it in and R&O give us 4 more bars, equaling 13 statements of "I'm in love" which culminates in an exciting, brassy, full orchestra, rip-off-hat moment. Nellie is in love a wonderful guy.

I might be way off, but this is what I think.
You can listen to Mary Martin sing the song here